The Nets Are Scorching

Brook Lopez Will Be Rookie Of The Year

.With the season winding down, and the Nets no longer in contention for the final playoff spot, a lot of talk about the Nets have revolved around Brook Lopez and whether or not he is going to be the Rookie Of The Year.  Brook definitely has a good shot at winning this (and the Nets must think so as well, because they have put out a promotional video, highlighting some of his stats and showing some of his biggest highlights), but he does have competition, and that competition is Derrick Rose.  In the end, one of these two players are going to win ROY, so I am going to compare these two and show you who I think should win Rookie Of The Year (hint it’s Brook) and who will win it.

Why Brook Should Win It:

The numbers.  Brook has been a solid producer from the get go and when it comes to rookie big men, this is a rarity.  Brook has started 70 of the team’s 77 games, and averages 30.5 minutes a game.  In those minutes, he is averaging 13 points a game (which is 6th among all rookies), and 7.9 rebounds a game (which is 2nd among all rookies).  Brook is also the only rookie with over 100 blocks (139 to be exact), while averaging over 1 block per game (1.8 to be exact).  Among all NBA players (not just rookies, the whole NBA), Brook is 7th in total blocks and 10th in blocks per game.  Also, for what it is worth, Brook is in the top 20 of all rookies in assists (1.1 per game), so he is getting the job done in all facets of his game.  Brook is 3rd among all rookies in double-doubles, and his shooting percentage (53.2%) is 6th among rookies, but of rookies who are averaging over 10 shots per game, Brook leads in FG% (This in my opinion is very important.  It shows that Brook is good enough to get the touches, and when he does, he converts them).

Derrick’s numbers are not shabby at all, but in my opinion they just don’t compare.  Derrick is 2nd in PPG among all rookies with 16.6, and he is also first in assists with 6.2 (but that tends to happen when you are the starting PG for your team, and when he is out there, it is arguable that he is the first option for the Bulls.  Meanwhile, Brook is 3rd option for the Nets on good nights…).  Other than that, Brook has him topped in all other categories (and this is with Derrick playing about 6 more minutes per game than Brook).

The final and in my opinion most important stat is PER, and this too shows Brook is more productive than Derrick with the time he is being given.  If you don’t know what PER is, you can find out more about it here, but basically it is a per-minute assessment of players (and it is also pace-adjusted as well).  Brook is 4th among rookies with a 17.87 PER (he is only behind Marreese Speights, Kevin Love, and Greg Oden).  Derrick Rose is 9th on the list with a PER of 15.66.  Another efficiency stat that I looked at was VA or Value Added (this number is the estimated number of points a player adds to a team’s season total above what a “replacement player” (for instance, the 12th man on the roster) would produce. Value Added = ([Minutes * (PER - PRL)] / 67). PRL (Position Replacement Level) = 11.5 for power forwards, 11.0 for point guards, 10.6 for centers, 10.5 for shooting guards and small forwards).  Brook leads all rookies with a VA of 254.7 (Derrick Rose is 4th with 194.6).  The final effciency stat that I looked at was EWA or Estimated Wins Added (Like Value Added, Estimated Wins Added takes a look at how many wins a player was worth above what a “replacement player” would contribute.  Estimated Wins Added is Value Added divided by 30, giving the estimated number of wins a player adds to a team’s season total above what a “replacement player” would produce).  Brook leads all rookies in EWA with 8.5 (Derrick Rose is 4th with 6.5).  These stats show that Brook is overall more effective with the minutes he receives, and that he is worth 3 whole wins more to his team than D. Rose is.

Why Derrick Should Win It

Success of his team.  While the Nets contended for a playoff spot until later in the season, Derrick Rose has been running point for a Bulls squad that has pretty much locked up a playoff spot (Most analysts didn’t have them even sniffing at the playoffs), and they are even challenging for the 7th or 6th (which may be a stretch)  seed.  Despite individual awards being handed out based on individual achievments, it would be naive to think that the people handing out the hardware won’t look at team performence.  This is especially true for the Rookie of The Year award.

So Who Will Win It?

You already know that I think Brook should win it, but who WILL win it?  If you want my honest opinion, it is going to be a tough call and you can really go either way with this one.  I decided to look at the trends to see how the award has been given out recently.  Looking at ROY award winners since 2001, only 3 have been guards.  The winning team trend has also been broken, none of the winners in the 2000s has lead their team to the playoffs.  This looks good for Brook, and I think in the end his production will be too much to overlook, and he will end up winning the ROY.  If Derrick Rose wins it you can’t get too mad though, he had a great season and did lead the Bulls to the playoffs.  There is even a possibility for a co-ROY, but if they didn’t do it when Carmelo and LeBron were rookies, I don’t see them doing it now.

About these ads

April 7, 2009 - Posted by | Brook Lopez, Offseason, Offseason Awards, Rookies | , ,

2 Comments »

  1. [...] Saturday Night’s game at home against the Magic is now officially “Brookie Night.”  Brookie, that is so awesome, I wish I would have come up with that.  The Nets, who are continuing their Brook Lopez for ROY campaign, will be giving out the above T-Shirts to the first 500 fans in attendence Saturday Night.  I was thinking about going to see this game anyway (Brook vs. Dwight should be a great matchup – Skip vs. Devin Harris too), but now I think I have to go and get one of these shirts, the comic book cover style looks awesome!  It is going to be a great collector’s item when he wins the Rookie of the Year. [...]

    Pingback by Saturday vs. The Magic Will Be “Brookie Night” « The Nets Are Scorching | April 8, 2009 | Reply

  2. [...] I already broke down the reasons why Brook Lopez was better than Derrick Rose, so I am not going to do it again here (Although if you use the transitive property, if [...]

    Pingback by Nets Are Scorching » Blog Archive » Derrick Rose Wins ROY. Brook Lopez Comes In…Third? | April 23, 2009 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: